Benjamin Britten composed his sensational War Requiem 16 years after the end of World War II. Britten suffered great personal losses in the War – the piece was dedicated to Roger Burney, Piers Dunkerley, David Gill, and Michael Halliday, two of whom died at war.
Our membership is full of singers whose families have been touched by war. Remembrance is very important to us as a choir – you can read about the ways in which we honour that every year here.
To commemorate our singers’ own personal stories, we spoke with two of them in detail about their family members’ stories, both on and off the battlefield.
Mark, Tenor 2
TBC: What’s your name, and what’s your voice type?
“My name is Mark and I’m a Tenor 2 in The Bach Choir.”
TBC: What was your father’s role in World War II?
Mark: “My father was a classicist and joined the forces at the outbreak of World War II. He was in the Rifle Brigade and went in as part of the Normandy landings on the D-Day plus 6, which I think was on 12th June 1944. My father was not a military person. By his own admission, he was a very poor soldier, but he joined the intelligence unit of the Rifle Brigade and did a lot of sorting out of information from the remains of battlefields and that sort of thing – he’d work out which German troops had been where, which Panzer divisions had been where and this was was fed back as intelligence. But he was not really a fighting man – at the end of the war, his revolver was completely rusted up because he had never had to use it!”
TBC: What did your father do outside of the War?
Mark: “My father was a dyed-in-wool academic, interested in scripture particularly, and languages. He was up at Oxford when the war broke out. He was briefly a Don at Wadham College, Oxford, after the war, but the war changed what he did in as much as he decided that he wanted to go into the education of younger children, and particularly because he was dismayed at the lack of education and the brainwashing within the Hitler Youth that he came across.”
TBC: Do you have any stories about your father?
Mark: “The worst experience my father describes in his memoir is fighting on Hill 112 in Normandy, which was a strategically very important, though very small hill with surrounding flat plains. He fought on the day they arrived there and was mightily relieved when he was tactically removed from the area and his position was taken by the Duke of Cornwall Light Infantry. That troop lost 70% of their men on Hill 112.
I discovered later that in amongst the Duke of Cornwall Light Infantry was a certain David Willcocks, who became the musical director of The Bach Choir, who auditioned me in 1972 and with whom I sang for 30 years. And these two men, who were together probably two of the most formative people in my life, passed on that day without ever meeting. In fact they never met, but they were very, very close in rather strange circumstances.”
How do you like to remember your father?
Mark: “Well, my father would not want to have been remembered as a soldier. He would far rather have been remembered as an educator and classicist and a headmaster with some radical views.”
TBC: Does singing or hearing the War Requiem spark any feelings related to your father?
Mark: “The War Requiem sparks lots of emotions for me and certainly in relation to my father. The abiding sensation I get from the War Requiem is the futility of war. The fighting on Hill 112 was perhaps the ultimate example of futility. Thousands of lives were lost for no territorial gain. And I think that that’s what the War Requiem means to me. The noise of battle, the futility mixed with absolutely achingly beautiful arias and poetry which sometimes adversity brings out in artists.”
John, Bass 2
What’s your name, and what’s your voice type?
John: “Hello, my name’s John and I’m a 1st Bass in the Bach Choir. I joined in 2012.”
Who are you here to talk about?
John: “I’m here to talk about Neil. Neil was my father-in-law many years ago. He died a long time ago.”
What was Neil’s role in World War II?
John: “Neil was born in what was then India, but returned to the UK by boat after the war started. His father died on that boat, so he went through an incredible time. And then he joined the Royal Air Force at the age of 17. And I don’t know much about his service, except that he met his wife in the RAF at an airbase in Lincolnshire. And for a while he was posted to Alexandria, and from Alexandria he was involved in bombing raids on southern Italy.”
TBC: What did Neil do outside of the War?
John: “After the war, Neil settled in Huddersfield with Monica, his wife, that’s where she was from, and was sort of adopted by her family. He worked for many years for one of the local engineering firms. By the time I knew him, he’d retired, and during the time I knew him, they moved over to the west coast near Blackpool.
He was really into sport. He played a lot of sport in his day. There were lots of jokes about Monica being a cricket widow. The other thing I do remember very well is how much he looked after and how much he played with my then very young children.”
TBC: Do you have any stories about Neil’s time in the War?
John: “Neil was quiet, he was a man of few words. He was a man’s man, he wasn’t chatty. But there were a couple of stories he told me, I think it was around the 50th anniversary of VE Day, back in the 90s. And so there was talk of that time, of course. There were two stories that he told me, I think perhaps because I wasn’t one of his own children, and so it was easier to tell me. And they really stuck in my mind.
The first story he told me happened when he was posted to Alexandria in the RAF. When he arrived, they were short of supplies, and there was no camp bed for him. But after a little while, a camp bed appeared. But what he understood was that he got a camp bed because someone else had been killed in action. And his comment on this to me was: “it puts strange ideas in your head, sleeping in a dead man’s bed”. And I found this an extraordinary thing to say. It’s the kind of thing that some people, it just wouldn’t bother at all. But it felt like this had been playing on his mind for 50 years, really. It showed sensitivity and vulnerability, I think. And also how troubled he was, really, by what he was going through.
The other thing that he told me was an anecdote. This must have been when he was in Lincolnshire. They had a crew in a plane, and one of the crew just lay on the floor and couldn’t or wouldn’t do anything. And the rest of the crew covered for him for the first time. But after it happened a second time, they felt they had to report it. And this man was demoted or disciplined or something, I think. And the phrase was that he was found to be ‘lacking moral fibre’, which is so redolent of the time. I guess we have such a different language now. Perhaps we’d be wondering whether this guy had PTSD or something like that. I think Neil knew that they had to report him because they would have enough on flying a bomber without being one man down before they’d even done anything. I think the state this man was in really troubled him, and that also staggers me.”
TBC: How do you like to remember Neil?
John: “I knew Neil when my children were very young. And my main memory of him is in relation to my children. So when my son was a baby and wouldn’t go to sleep, I remember Neil just rocking and rocking his pram seemingly for hours with sort of endless patience. And then when they were a bit older, I just had all these memories of him playing with them. Plastic seems to come into it because it would be a plastic cricket bat or a plastic guitar or a plastic drum. And there’s Neil sort of joining in and just being, just enjoying being with them. I think they gave him a lot of pleasure and he certainly gave them a lot of pleasure. And it’s a really lovely memory of him.”
TBC: Does singing or hearing the War Requiem spark any feelings related to your father?
John: “My memories of Neil are not things that particularly come to mind when I listen to the War Requiem. I have a sort of bigger reaction I suppose. I’ve known it for such a long time, this piece. And the older I get, the more powerful it seems to be and the more incredible I think it is. It’s, I mean the music is just amazing and the way that he uses all of the incredible forces at his disposal. But overall, it’s just the anger that he expresses, and the power with which he denounces not just war itself but the powers that make it happen who don’t stop it. Everyone should hear it.”
Britten’s War Requiem so accurately captures the horrors of war and the hope for a brighter future that we all hold. Our 1963 recording of this work was ranked as the third best recording of all time by BBC Music Magazine. You can listen to the album on Spotify here, and you can read the full story of how that special recording happened here.